Transformational Parenting...
  Transformational Parenting
  • Home
  • About
    • Mia Von Scha
    • Contact
    • Fee Structure
    • Testimonials
    • What is EMDR?
  • Services
    • Infant therapy
    • Play therapy
    • Teen counselling
    • Parenting coaching
    • Life coaching
    • Schools
    • Workshops
  • Inspiration
    • Parenting Blog
    • Podcasts
    • MindBytes Videos
  • Kids Books

Stop Asking Your Kids This One Question...

1/8/2018

2 Comments

 
The one question you shouldn't be asking your child.
We ask our kids a lot of questions in the course of a regular week. How was school? What did you do? Have you brushed your teeth? How was your outing? Have you done your homework? Who did you play with? What are you eating? Why aren’t you eating? How was the party?
 
I’m not really a fan of asking kids lots of questions at all. Asking questions can show that we don’t trust our children. It doesn’t respect their right to tell only what they feel like telling or not to elaborate until they’ve processed something themselves. It can feel like interrogation. It can seem intrusive. It directs conversations in ways that often miss the depth and essence of what a child has to tell us.
 
Then again, our kids tend to ask us a lot of questions as well. We’ve already talked about why we shouldn’t necessarily answer them. Maybe I’ll put out a memo to kids not to answer their parents’ questions too!
 
So I realize I won’t get you to stop asking questions completely, but there is one question that you absolutely need to banish from your list. And that question is…


What to you want to be when you grow up?
 
I dislike this question for a number of reasons:
 
Firstly, it assumes that your child is not already somebody now. We need to focus instead on who the child is in this moment. What do they enjoy? Which things inspire them? What makes them feel alive? Who are they right now?
 
We need to stop seeing childhood as just a stage along the way to becoming an adult - As if only adults are fully human. Being a human is an ongoing process. We are complete (and not) in every single phase. We are not on our way to some final destination (other than, maybe, death).
 
Secondly, it assumes a future. And it invites children to only see the present as a means to fulfilling some future desire. Who says they will have a future? Many children do not grow up – literally. And why should they spend these amazing, alive, vibrant years of their lives only preparing for sometime in some uncertain future instead of fully engaging with and enjoying right now?
 
Thirdly, this question assumes that what you do equates to who you are. I may be a parenting coach, but I am also a student, a mother, a wife, a friend, a chef, a chauffeur, a child, a sister, a hiker, a swimmer, a dancer, a writer… and a host of other things depending on the day or time or year that you ask me. None of these labels capture who I fundamentally am.
 
And finally, the question assumes that our children will have only one career in their lives. This is highly highly unlikely. It may have been true two generations ago, but it is definitely not the case anymore. Most people will have multiple careers. Training our children to think in terms of one lifelong career will set them up for disappointment. How many of you have thought that you were supposed to have this one driving passion that you pursued? And how many of you actually found that to be the case? Most of us have messier lives than that – we follow hunches and curiosities and fall into things and fall out of things and try multiple things and abandon most of them. That lie that we were supposed to have one life mission (and that it would be career related) all started for us in that nasty little question – what do you want to be when you grow up?
 
Personally, as a child, I wish that instead of being asked that question, I had been asked - who do you feel like being right now? And then been given the permission to just go with that – to embrace that curiosity in that moment and see what journey it might have taken me on.
 
A child cannot decide at 4 or 14 what path their life should take. Most of us can’t even do that at 40. So let’s abandon that question and instead of asking any question, let’s just observe our children being who they are at any moment in time. They already are someone. Themselves. And aren’t they just magnificent?
 

Are you still trying to find your path in life? My Parenting Breakthrough Experience is designed to help you to love your life exactly as it is. Sign up now!
2 Comments
raj link
22/5/2023 09:46:27 am

thanks to you

Reply
Make My Kid Star link
22/5/2023 10:15:37 am

Thanks to you. Sometimes we unintentionally say things to people that we should not. Now I understand how to communicate with children in a way that does not harm them.

Reply



Leave a Reply.


    ADHD: Alternatives to Medication

    Gain a strong understanding of natural, sustainable alternatives for ADHD children and how to implement these yourself.
    Gain a strong understanding of natural, sustainable alternatives for ADHD children and how to implement these yourself in this online course.
    Start learning now!

    Mia also writes parenting articles for:

    Visit my profile on YourTango Experts

    Mia Von Scha, life and parenting coach, writes for Jozikids.

    Mia Von Scha, life and parenting coach, writes for Mail & Guardian.

    Mia Von Scha, life and parenting expert, writes for SA Moms.

    Mia Von Scha, life and parenting expert writes for Parenting Hub.

    Radio show to help you to be the change you want to see in your children.

    RSS Feed


© Mia Von Scha 2012